In an effort to learn from some of the world’s biggest celebrities, we reached out to them to hear their response to this one simple question:
What’s your favorite restaurant in NYC and why?
Here are their responses, which are shared in the order that they were received:
2. “Buddha Bodai on Mott st, Chinatown. Kosher vegan dim sum. Need I say more?! The vegan BBQ pork bao and anything actually with BBQ pork will leave you obsessing over your next fix. Amazing authentic dim sum in an authentic dim sum venue. Yum. Dun-Well Doughnuts. Brooklyn. Vegan artisan doughnuts that win awards for best doughnut overall – not just vegan. The consistency is absolutely the doughnut of your dreams, and the artisan rotating variety of amazing toppings makes this place just the best. Plus, the down home old time doughnut shop feel makes it a total experience worth going to Brooklyn for sure!”
3. “Chalk Point Kitchen offers a fine dining experience in hip Soho with easy access from several Subway stations. The restaurant offers a classy flair for small details, a minimal, yet elegant decor, a well-stocked wine bar and skilled mixologists. These ingredients, together, result in a tantalizing menu of fresh, seasonal dishes and craft cocktails for the most distinguished palates. Overall, the food is delicious and the atmosphere has a warm yet upscale ‘neighborhood eatery feel!'”
I am a big big fan and love two things about this amazing Italian Family restaurant;It goes without saying that the service from management to waiter is always a delight. Whether you are a regular or first timer you will be greeted with a smile and love. But what really matters is the food! I love their Caesar Salad to start. Hey if that is all I ordered it would be great cause the portions are so large that it really is difficult to eat everything on your plate. For the main dish two of my all time faves are Chicken Scarpariello, and for a splurge their Porterhouse Steak. Remember the portions are huge – family style- so plan for one dish to serve at least 4 people. That is why it is affordable. Their deserts which are also huge are a serious delight regardless of which one you choose. For me however their tiramisu is my choice.
The second reason I love Carmines, is that when I look around and see tables of 6 or 8 or big family parties, I am happy that the dinner they are enjoying, is affordable and plentiful.
When a group of people stop me on the street ask me if they can afford to eat out? My answer is YOU ARE APPROVED if you are eating at Carmine’s!”
5. “That’s a tough question. I think every New Yorker has their favorite little out of the way places. These are the places you share with friends or you “one up” with people when you’re talking food. I have a lot of those. The city is filled with little places that do the best ‘this or that’. And I leave it to anyone to get out and explore and find those places. My favorite restaurant is Hillstone. True New Yorkers might wince at a chain but I find the difficulty with any restaurant in the city is consistency.
Will your favorite place live up to your expectations time and time again? Hillstone does. It’s atmospheric despite it’s rather big footprint. You can hear the people you’re dining with and the menu is diverse. Do yourself a favor and try the kale salad. The sushi is great, the steaks are great and don’t tell my mother but their Famous French Dip sandwich is the best I’ve ever had hands down. It’s a place I get excited to go to. Like a little kid to and ice cream parlour kind of excited.”
6. “Picking one favorite New York restaurant on the basis of the food is impossible–There are too many great options. I love Juliana’s for pizza, Second Avenue Deli for pastrami, and a million others I can’t think of. But I’d like to put forth a Middle Eastern restaurant called Ali Baba, on Amsterdam on the Upper West Side, because eating there is a quintessentially New York experience.
It’s a hole in the wall with the best shawarma I’ve had in America. There’s only one table, so everyone eats together. The last time I was there I sat with a Japanese university professor, two Hasidic Jews, and a guy visiting from the midwest. Then a Croatian came in carrying a cello. He said he had never had falafel before, and the room went silent as he took his first ever bite. He liked it. He was one of us.
7. “To pick one restaurant in the US is tough! I’ve been offered some amazing hospitality and good food in a lot of places, but one of my favorite spots is Vitae in NYC. It’s such a good place to unwind in the hustle and bustle of the big city. They take such good care of us when we eat there, and the food is always delish! I leave there stuffed and happy every time. They always have something that fits my mood. Homemade pastas, yummy pork schnitzel, or scallops with a curry sauce, and I always make sure to save room for dessert!”
8. “My favorite all-around restaurant in NYC is probably Gramercy Tavern. There are so many great places in that city, and there are so many spots that I love the most depending on my mood and hunger. But if I could only dine once more in the city ever again it would have to be Gramercy. I’ve never had anything short of a spectacular meal there. They truly grasp seasonal cooking and do it with style and flair, but never as a gimmick. Everything from the cheese selection to the wines, the decor to the service, and of course the menus – is perfect. Go there now!”
9. “My favorite restaurant in NYC is Parm, hands down. This Italian-American joint makes my ideal comfort food. From the classic chicken parm to the inventive B&G Poppers and the charming ice cream cake to finish on the meal – this place does comfort right. The atmosphere is laid back, the food is always good, and I always leave happy and well fed.”
10. “My favorite restaurant in NYC is ABC Kitchen because everything is not only delicious, but it’s all organic and so fresh. I love the decor inside as well.”
11. “I’m going to stick close to home on this one. My wife and I live in a rather, um, “up and coming” area of Queens, surrounded by taxi repair shops and industrial warehouses. So when Café Ole opened up five years ago, it was a dream come true. The menu doesn’t exactly re-invent the Spanish food wheel (tapas, paella, etc.), but each dish is perfectly prepared and the fish is always fresh as fresh gets. Oh, and the sangria kicks ass.
12. “I find myself always returning to and recommending Ballato’s, especially when I’m craving a perfect spaghetti al pomodoro that takes me straight back to Italy, zucchini fritte, tre colore salad, and plates of their warm house focaccia bread to start. Located on an unexceptional stretch of Houston Street, within walking distance of Little Italy, but a world apart, I’ve spotted big-time celebs on multiple visits – I know they love it because it’s so cozy and off-the-radar. It is completely irresistible and a piece of old New York – a true locals only joint.”
13. “Favorite NYC eatery? Impossible to choose! Depends on what I’m in the mood for. Lavo has a ginormous Kobe meatball with whipped fresh ricotta you must have at least once before you die, and the eggplant parmigiano appetizer is spectacular. The steaks at Quality Meats are wonderful (ribeye aged to perfection!), but I’d be perfectly happy just loading up on appetizers and dessert. Their signature corn creme brûlée is worth an extra 30 minutes on the elliptical as is a “dressed up” scoop of their homemade ice cream. Coffee and doughnuts, please!
But since I try to eat healthy most of the time, my favorite seafood spot is Catch. While in the trendy part of town (Meatpacking District), it has an earthy, chill kind of vibe with very attentive service. The simply grilled fish dishes come with a variety of savory sauce options– I’m partial to grilled salmon or mahi-mahi with mango-pineapple salsa– and the rolls are mouthwatering, each with a unique twist. Spider Roll with crab, avocado and sweet chili garlic gets the nod every time!”
Already got that next date night planned out?! We’re happy to hear. If you liked this post, feel free to share with all your foodie friends. Bon Appétit!
PS- If you haven’t already, be sure to check out similar posts 13 Restaurant Recommendations from Top Food Experts and 17 LA Restaurant Recommendations From Top Hollywood Celebrities.